Effective length can be found easily on isolated columns by
using Table C-C2 in the Commentary of the Specification
Section of the Manual. However, this
table will not work very well with rigid frames. Columns in
a frame are not independent, they are continuous. The
buckling of one member will affect all the members around
it. Therefore, the end conditions necessary for using Table
C-C2 are not sufficient. It is important to account for the
degree of restraint by connecting members of a column in a
frame.
A frame can be unbraced or braced, where unbraced means
horizontal displacement in possible. A frame can also have
sidesway.
"The rotational restraint provided by beams, or girders, at
the end of a column is a function of rotational stiffnesses
of the members intersecting at the joint." LRFD Steel
Design Second Edition -- William T. Segui, 1999. The
restraint is proportional to
EIL
E
I
L
.
G=∑
E
c
I
c
L
c
∑
E
g
I
g
L
g
=∑
I
c
L
c
∑
I
g
L
g
G
E
c
I
c
L
c
E
g
I
g
L
g
I
c
L
c
I
g
L
g
(1)
KK, then depends on the ratio
of column stiffness to the girder stiffness at each end.
KK is relatively small when a
slender column is connected to a girder of large cross
section. This is because the girder effectively prevents
rotation and acts as a fixed end. The
GG value for this case is
rather small too. KK (or
GG) is relatively large when
the ends of very stiff columns are connected to rather
flexible beams. This is because the ends of the column can
more freely rotate and approach the pinned condition.
"The relationship between GG
and KK has been quantified in
the Jackson-Mooreland Alignment Charts (Johnston, 1796),
which are reproduced in Figure C-C2.2 in the Commentary. To
obtain a value of KK from one
of the nomograms, first calculate the value of
GG at each end of the column,
letting one value be
G
A
G
A
and the other be
G
B
G
B
. Connect
G
A
G
A
and
G
B
G
B
with a straight line, and read the value of
KK on the middle scale. The
effective length factor obtained in this manner is with
respect to the axis of bending, which is the axis
perpendicular to the plane of the frame. A separate
analysis must be made for buckling about the other axis.
Normally the beam-to-column connections in this direction
will not transmit moment, sidesway is prevented by bracing,
and KK can be taken as 1.0.
GG can be taken as 10 at a
pinned support because at a pin connection, the situation is
just like a very stiff column attached to infinitely
flexible girders. This means the girders have zero
stiffness. Then, the ratio of column stiffness to girder
stiffness would be infinite for a perfectly frictionless
hinge. This end condition can only be approximated in
practice, so the discussion accompanying the alignment chart
recommends that GG be taken as 10.