Position

Definition 1: Position

The position of a particle is a point in the defined volumetric space of the coordinate system.

Figure 2: Position of a point is specified by three coordinate values

Position of a point object

The position of a point like object, in three dimensional coordinate space, is defined by three values of coordinates i.e. x, y and z in Cartesian coordinate system as shown in the figure above.

It is evident that the relative position of a point with respect to a fixed point such as the origin of the system “O” has directional property. The position of the object, for example, can lie either to the left or to the right of the origin or at a certain angle from the positive x - direction. As such the position of an object is associated with directional attribute with respect to a frame of reference (coordinate system).

Example 1: Coordinates

Problem : The length of the second’s hand of a round wall clock is ‘r’ meters. Specify the coordinates of the tip of the second’s hand corresponding to the markings 3,6,9 and 12 (Consider the center of the clock as the origin of the coordinate system.).

Figure 3: The origin coincides with the center

Coordinates of the tip of the second’s hand

Solution : The coordinates of the tip of the second’s hand is given by the coordinates :

3  :   r,  0,  0
6  :   0, -r,  0
9  :  -r,  0,  0
12 :   0,  r,  0

Exercise 1

What would be the coordinates of the markings 3,6,9 and 12 in the earlier example, if the origin coincides with the marking 6 on the clock ?

Figure 4: Origin coincides with the marking 6 O’ clock

Coordinates of the tip of the second’s hand

Solution 1

The coordinates of the tip of the second’s hand is given by the coordinates :

3  :   r,  r,  0
6  :   0,  0,  0
9  :  -r,  r,  0
12 :   0, 2r,  0

[ Click for Solution 1 ] [ Hide Solution 1 ]

The above exercises point to an interesting feature of the frame of reference: that the specification of position of the object (values of coordinates) depends on the choice of origin of the given frame of reference. We have already seen that description of motion depends on the state of observer i.e. the attached system of reference. This additional dependence on the choice of origin of the reference would have further complicated the issue, but for the linear distance between any two points in a given system of reference, is found to be independent of the choice of the origin. For example, the linear distance between the markings 6 and 12 is ‘2r’, irrespective of the choice of the origin.

Plotting motion

Position of a point in the volumetric space is a three dimensional description. A plot showing positions of an object during a motion is an actual description of the motion in so far as the curve shows the path of the motion and its length gives the distance covered. A typical three dimensional motion is depicted as in the figure below :

Figure 5: The plot is the path followed by the object during motion.

Motion in three dimension

In the figure, the point like object is deliberately shown not as a point, but with finite dimensions. This has been done in order to emphasize that an object of finite dimensions can be treated as point when the motion is purely translational.

The three dimensional description of positions of an object during motion is reduced to be two or one dimensional description for the planar and linear motions respectively. In two or one dimensional motion, the remaining coordinates are constant. In all cases, however, the plot of the positions is meaningful in following two respects :

Description of motion

Position is the basic element used to describe motion. Scalar properties of motion like distance and speed are expressed in terms of position as a function of time. As the time passes, the positions of the motion follow a path, known as the trajectory of the motion. It must be emphasized here that the path of motion (trajectory) is unique to a frame of reference and so is the description of the motion.

To illustrate the point, let us consider that a person is traveling on a train, which is moving with the velocity v along a straight track. At a particular moment, the person releases a small pebble. The pebble drops to the ground along the vertical direction as seen by the person.

Figure 6: Trajectory is a straight line.

Trajectory as seen by the passenger

The same incident, however, is seen by an observer on the ground as if the pebble followed a parabolic path (See Figure blow). It emerges then that the path or the trajectory of the motion is also a relative attribute, like other attributes of the motion (speed and velocity). The coordinate system of the passenger in the train is moving with the velocity of train (v) with respect to the earth and the path of the pebble is a straight line. For the person on the ground, however, the coordinate system is stationary with respect to earth. In this frame, the pebble has a horizontal velocity, which results in a parabolic trajectory.

Figure 7: Trajectory is a parabolic curve.

Trajectory as seen by the person on ground

Without overemphasizing, we must acknowledge that the concept of path or trajectory is essentially specific to the frame of reference or the coordinate system attached to it. Interestingly, we must be aware that this particular observation happens to be the starting point for the development of special theory of relativity by Einstein (see his original transcript on the subject of relativity).

Position – time plot

The position in three dimensional motion involves specification in terms of three coordinates. This requirement poses a serious problem, when we want to investigate positions of the object with respect to time. In order to draw such a graph, we would need three axes for describing position and one axis for plotting time. This means that a position – time plot for a three dimensional motion would need four (4) axes !

A two dimensional position – time plot, however, is a possibility, but its drawing is highly complicated for representation on a two dimensional paper or screen. A simple example consisting of a linear motion in the x-y plane is plotted against time on z – axis (See Figure).

Figure 8:

Two dimensional position – time plot

As a matter of fact, it is only the one dimensional motion, whose position – time plot can be plotted conveniently on a plane. In one dimensional motion, the point object can either be to the left or to the right of the origin in the direction of reference line. Thus, drawing position against time is a straight forward exercise as it involves plotting positions with appropriate sign.

Example 2: Coordinates

Problem : A ball moves along a straight line from O to A to B to C to O along x-axis as shown in the figure. The ball covers each of the distance of 5 m in one second. Plot the position – time graph.

Figure 9:

Motion along a straight line

Solution : The coordinates of the ball are 0,5,10, -5 and 0 at points O, A, B, C and O (on return) respectively. The position – time plot of the motion is as given below :

Figure 10:

Position – time plot in one dimension

Exercise 2

A ball falling from a height ‘h’ strikes a hard horizontal surface with increasing speed. On each rebound, the height reached by the ball is half of the height it fell from. Draw position – time plot for the motion covering two consecutive strikes, emphasizing the nature of curve (ignore actual calculation).

Solution 2

Now, as the ball falls towards the surface, it covers path at a quicker pace. As such, the position changes more rapidly as the ball approaches the surface. The curve (i.e. plot) is, therefore, steeper towards the surface. On the return upward journey, the ball covers lesser distance as it reaches the maximum height. Hence, the position – time curve (i.e. plot) is flatter towards the point of maximum height.

Figure 11:

Position – time plot in one dimension

[ Click for Solution 2 ] [ Hide Solution 2 ]

Exercise 3

The figure below shows three position – time plots of a motion of a particle along x-axis. Giving reasons, identify the valid plot(s) among them. For the valid plot(s), determine following :

Figure 12

Position – time plots in one dimension

1. How many times the particle has come to rest?
2. Does the particle reverse its direction during motion?

Solution 3

Validity of plots : In the portion of plot I, we can draw a vertical line that intersects the curve at three points. It means that the particle is present at three positions simultaneously, which is not possible. Plot II is also not valid for the same reason. Besides, it consists of a vertical portion, which would mean presence of the particle at infinite numbers of positions at the same instant. Plot III, on the other hand, is free from these anomalies and is the only valid curve representing motion of a particle along x – axis (See Figure).

Figure 13: A particle can not be present at more than one position at a given instant.

Valid position – time plot in one dimension

When the particle comes to rest, there is no change in the value of “x”. This, in turn, means that tangent to the curve at points of rest is parallel to x-axis. By inspection, we find that tangent to the curve is parallel to x-axis at four points (B,C,D and E) on the curve shown in the figure below. Hence, the particle comes to rest four times during the motion.

Figure 14: At rest, the tangent to the path is parallel to time axis.

Positions of rest

[ Click for Solution 3 ] [ Hide Solution 3 ]