Skip to content Skip to navigation

OpenStax-CNX

You are here: Home » Content » Force and invariant mass

Navigation

Recently Viewed

This feature requires Javascript to be enabled.
 

Force and invariant mass

Module by: Sunil Kumar Singh. E-mail the author

Summary: Different forms of Newton’s laws of motion are consistent with each other in classical mechanics.

Note: You are viewing an old version of this document. The latest version is available here.

Newton’s second law is stated in terms of either time rate of change of momentum or as a product of mass and acceleration.

F = ( m v ) t F = ( m v ) t

and

F = m a F = m a

There is a bit of debate (even difference of opinion) about the forms (momentum .vs. acceleration) in which Newton’s second law is presented – particularly with respect to consideration of mass as invariant or otherwise. In this module, we shall discuss to resolve this issue.

As far as classical mechanics is concerned, we shall see that the difference of opinion is actually the difference of approach, which does not change the basic understanding of force or its relationship with acceleration as we understand from Newton’s second law. The views are consistent and convey same physical meaning. Only thing is that we must accurately know what each form of relation means and what each concept represents.

However, the two forms of force defining relations are not equivalent in relativistic mechanics. Here, the definition of force in terms of mass and acceleration is completely different than that in classical mechanics.

Mass invariance

First thing that we must clearly understand that invariance of mass is a scientific reality only in restricted sense. We know that mass of a body depends on its speed and that the change is significant at high speed. However if we exclude the change in mass of a body at high speed, then “given” mass is essentially invariant in classical mechanics (where speed is relatively smaller with respect to speed of light).

Mass variance in classical mechanics

However, we come across situation even in Newtonian mechanics, in which we find that mass of a body under study is actually changing. This change results as there is exchange of mass between the body system and its surrounding. Th motion of rocket launched in space or a leaking balloon are examples of changing mass system. But, we must understand that this is not the change of “given” mass; rather mass is simply distributed from one body system (say balloon)into two or more body systems (balloon and its surrounding).

Figure 1: The air gushing out of the balloon generates an external force on balloon.
Leaking balloon
 Leaking balloon  (imf1.gif)

Now, does this variance of mass have any bearing on the form of Newton’s second law or about the meaning of force as acceleration of unit mass? This is the question that we need to answer. Now, let us consider the situation in terms of Newton’s second law (Here we consider one dimensional case only to keep the discussion focused) :

F = ( m v ) t F = m v t + v m t F = m a + v m t F = ( m v ) t F = m v t + v m t F = m a + v m t

Apparently, this mass variant form of Newton’s second law appears to destroy the well founded meaning of force as the acceleration of unit mass. As a matter of fact, it is not so.

Let us recall the relation, F = ma, which essentially underlines relation between force (cause) and acceleration (effect). Now look closely at the additional term resulting from change in mass in the context of a real time case like that of a rocket. Here, the body i.e. rocket is loosing mass with the escaping gas and hence dm < 0 i.e. change in mass is negative.

F = m a - v m t F = m a - v m t

The rocket is put into motion with expulsion of high speed gas. The escaping gas provides the thrust (force) to accelerate the rocket. What it means that the escaping gas mass is yet another body system which is applying force on the rocket and thereby constitutes external force to the rocket.

The additional term, therefore, is not an “effect” term like “ma”, but a term representing “external force”. Rewriting the equation to segregate cause and effect terms on either side of the equality, we have :

F + v m t = m a F + v m t = m a

F External = m a F External = m a

Thus, we see that a varying mass does not change the fundamental aspect of Newton’s second law of motion. It only modifies the external force on the body. The net external force is still equal to the product of mass and acceleration.

Example 1

Problem : Air from a leaking balloon of mass 15 gm gushes out at a constant speed of 10 m/s. The balloon shrinks completely in 10 seconds and reduces to a mass of 5 gm. Find the average force on the balloon.

Solution : There is no external force on balloon initially. However, gushing air constitutes an exchange of mass between balloon and its surrounding. This generates an external force on the balloon given by :

Figure 2: The air gushing out of the balloon generates an external force on balloon.
Leaking balloon
 Leaking balloon  (imf1.gif)

F avg = v x Δ m Δ t F avg = 10 x 0.015 - 0.005 10 F avg = 0.01 N F avg = v x Δ m Δ t F avg = 10 x 0.015 - 0.005 10 F avg = 0.01 N

We summarize the discussion held, in the context of classical mechanics, so far as :

  1. Given mass is invariant.
  2. The variance of the mass of body system is actually a redistribution of mass from one body system to more than one body systems.
  3. Irrespective of the nature of mass (varying or constant) of a body system, external force is equal to time rate change of momentum. As linear momentum is the product of mass and velocity, the linear momentum can change because of change in either of the two quantities in any combination.
  4. If there is redistribution of mass, then it results into an external force to the original body system, modifying the external force on the body.
  5. Irrespective of the nature of mass (varying or constant) of a body system, the net external force is equal to the product of mass and acceleration.
  6. Irrespective of the nature of mass (varying or constant) of a body system, momentum and acceleration forms of Newton’s second law are equivalent and consistent to each other.

Mass variance in relativistic mechanics

The detailed discussion of this topic is not part of the course. For information sake, we shall only outline the features of force law in relativistic mechanics. Here, momentum and acceleration forms are not equivalent. As a matter of fact, the momentum form is valid even in relativistic mechanics i.e.

F = p t F = p t

However, the acceleration form is not valid. For relativistic mechanics, this form is written, in terms of rest mass, m 0 m 0 , as :

F = m 0 a ( 1 - v 2 c 2 ) 1 2 + ( 1 - v 2 c 2 ) 3 2 m 0 v . a c 2 v F = m 0 a ( 1 - v 2 c 2 ) 1 2 + ( 1 - v 2 c 2 ) 3 2 m 0 v . a c 2 v

Yet another important aspect of force here is that force and acceleration vectors need not be parallel or in the same direction.

We summarize the discussion held, in the context of relativistic mechanics, so far as :

  1. Given mass is not invariant.
  2. The momentum and acceleration forms of Newton’s second law are not equivalent.
  3. Momentum form of Newton’s second law is valid.
  4. Acceleration form of Newton’s second law is not valid.
  5. Force and acceleration need not be in the same direction.

Content actions

Download module as:

Add module to:

My Favorites (?)

'My Favorites' is a special kind of lens which you can use to bookmark modules and collections. 'My Favorites' can only be seen by you, and collections saved in 'My Favorites' can remember the last module you were on. You need an account to use 'My Favorites'.

| A lens I own (?)

Definition of a lens

Lenses

A lens is a custom view of the content in the repository. You can think of it as a fancy kind of list that will let you see content through the eyes of organizations and people you trust.

What is in a lens?

Lens makers point to materials (modules and collections), creating a guide that includes their own comments and descriptive tags about the content.

Who can create a lens?

Any individual member, a community, or a respected organization.

What are tags? tag icon

Tags are descriptors added by lens makers to help label content, attaching a vocabulary that is meaningful in the context of the lens.

| External bookmarks