Summary: Appendices to The New-York Historical Society: Lessons from one Non-Profit's Long Struggle for Survival
Having formed an association, for the purpose of discovering, procuring, and preserving whatever may relate to the natural, civil, literary, and ecclesiastical history of our country, and particularly of the State of New-York, we solicit the aid of the liberal, patriotic, and learned, to promote the objects of our institution.
The utility of societies for the advancement of science, has been so fully proved by the experience of the most enlightened nations of Europe, and by that of our own country, that there can be no need, at this time, of any formal arguments in support of their claim to public patronage. But it may be observed, that, in this State, if we except the Agricultural Society, there is no association for the purposes of general knowledge; and the want of a regular, minute, and authentic History of New-York, renders the combined efforts of individuals for that object more peculiarly necessary.
It is well known that many valuable manuscripts and papers relative to the history of our country remain in the possession of those who, though unwilling to entrust them to a single person, yet would cheerfully confide them to a public institution, in whose custody they would be preserved for the general benefit of society. To rescue from the dust and obscurity of private repositories such important documents, as are liable to be lost or destroyed by the indifference or neglect of those into whose hands they may have fallen, will be a primary object of our attention.
The paucity of materials, and the extreme difficulty of procuring such as relate to the first settlement and colonial transactions of this State, can be fully perceived by those only who have meditated on the design of erecting an historical monument of those events, and have calculated the nature and amount of their resources: for without the aid of original records and authentic documents, history will be nothing more than a well-combined series of ingenious conjectures and amusing fables. The cause of truth is interesting to all men, and those who possess the means, however small, of preventing error, or of elucidating obscure facts, will confer a benefit on mankind by communicating them to the world.
Not aspiring to the higher walks of general science, we shall confine the range of our exertions to the humble task of collecting and preserving whatever may be useful to others in the different branches of historical inquiry. We feel encouraged to follow this path by the honorable example of the Massachusetts Society, whose labors will abridge those of the future historian, and furnish a thousand lights to guide him through the dubious track of unrecorded time. Without aiming to be rivals, we shall be happy to co-operate with that laudable institution in pursuing the objects of our common researches; satisfied if, in the end, our efforts shall be attended with equal success.
Our inquiries are not limited to a single State or district, but extend to the whole Continent; and it will be our business to diffuse the information we may collect in such manner as will best conduce to general instruction. As soon as our collection shall be sufficient to form a volume, and the funds of the Society will admit, we shall commence publication, that we may better secure our treasures by means of the press, from the corrosion of time and the power of accident.
That this object may be sooner and more effectually attained, we request that all who feel disposed to encourage our design will transmit, as soon as convenient, to the Society,
Manuscripts, Records, Pamphlets, and Books relative to the History of this Country, and particularly to the points of inquiry subjoined;
Orations, Sermons, Essays, Discourses, Poems, and Tracts; delivered, written, or published on any public occasion, or which concern any public transaction or remarkable character or event;
Laws, Journals, Copies of Records, and Proceedings of Congresses, Legislatures, General Assemblies, Conventions, Committees of Safety, Secret Committees for General Objects, Treaties and Negotiations with any Indian Tribes, or with any State or Nation;
Proceedings of Ecclesiastical Conventions, Synods, General Assemblies, Presbyteries, and Societies of all denominations of Christians;
Narratives of Missionaries, and Proceedings of Missionary Societies;
Narratives of Indian Wars, Battles, and Exploits; of the Adventures and Sufferings of Captives, Voyagers, and Travellers;
Minutes and Proceedings of Societies for the Abolition of Slavery, and the Transactions of Societies for Political, Literary, and Scientific Purposes;
Accounts of Universities, Colleges, Academies, and Schools; their origin, progress, and present state;
Topographical Descriptions of Cities, Towns, Counties, and Districts, at various periods, with Maps and whatever relates to the progressive Geography of the Country;
Statistical Tables—Tables of Diseases, Births and Deaths, and of Population; of Meteorological Observations, and Facts relating to Climate;
Accounts of Exports and Imports at various periods, and of the progress of Manufactures and Commerce;
Magazines, Reviews, Newspapers, and other Periodical Publications, particularly such as appeared antecedent to the year 1783;
Biographical Memoirs and Anecdotes of eminent and remarkable Persons in America, or who have been connected with its settlement or history;
Original Essays and Disquisitions on the Natural, Civil, Literary, or Ecclesiastical History of any State, City, Town, or District.
As the Society intend to form a Library and Cabinet, they will gratefully receive specimens of the various productions of the American Continent and of the adjacent Islands, and such animal, vegetable, and mineral subjects as may be deemed worthy of preservation. Donations also of rare and useful books and pamphlets relative to the above objects, will be thankfully accepted, and all communications duly noticed in the publications of the Society.
Queries as to Those Points on Which the Society Requests Particular Information
A critical component of this story has been the Society's evolving financial condition. Because of that fact, a detailed analysis of the Society's financial statements was conducted that reaches back to 1935, the year the Society received the $4.5 million Thompson bequest. There are certain problems in studying a time series of such length. Most significant, because the analysis uses data from the Society's annual reports and audited financial statements, it changes with the formats chosen by the Society's accountants and managers at the time. Occasionally, these changes make it difficult to keep presentation of the information consistent over time. To alleviate this problem, this analysis focuses on major financial categories only. From 1935 to 1974, the statements were, for the most part, comparable; however, in 1975, the Society converted from cash-based accounting to an accrual accounting system using complex (and very different) fund accounting concepts. Because of that change, the analysis of the tenure of James J. Heslin has been divided into two parts, 1960-1974 and 1975-1981.
The data shown in the tables that follow differ from what was originally presented in the Society's statements. The chief difference involves distinguishing between operating and capital activity. Unfortunately, nonprofit institutions are not required to prepare operating statements. Consequently, activities that are capital in nature, such as the receipt of endowment gifts or sales of real property, are often shown as part of the current operating performance of the institution. Inclusion of such cash inflows as operating income does not provide an accurate picture of an institution's operating stability, and every effort has been made to exclude such capital activity from the operating data.
What follows are brief summaries of the most significant assumptions, along with adjustments that have been made to the results, for the tables that follow.
1937: The Society included certain expenditures for the construction of its building. These amounts, totaling $51,000, were excluded from total operating expenditures.
1939: The Society borrowed approximately $25,000 from the endowment to cover a deficit, but it was shown as revenue. $25,000 was deducted from total operating revenue. The interfund loan was repaid in 1950.
1943: The Society purchased a neighboring lot at 15 West Seventy-Sixth Street for $25,000. That amount was deducted from total operating expenditures.
1950: The Society transferred $25,000 from operations to the endowment to retire the interfund loan taken in 1939 (no interest was paid). $25,000 was deducted from total operating expenditures.
1954: Several changes took place in the Society's accounts in this year. First, there were several capital transfers from operations (including a $15,000 transfer to a publications fund) totaling approximately $24,000, which has been deducted from total operating expenditures. The Society also established three board-designated funds, the accumulated surplus fund, a pension fund, and an accessions fund.
1955: After 1955, the Society began making transfers to fund its board-restricted pension account. In the Society's statements, the total amount of these transfers was shown as expenditure. This analysis adjusts the expenditure by deducting only the amount actually spent to pay benefits.
1966: $266,000 from the operating account was spent on the Society's building renovation. This amount has been deducted from total operating expenditures.
1967: Prior to 1967, investment income included only dividends and interest received. After 1967, when the Society adopted the total return investment policy, capital gains were realized to bring the investment income up to the spending limit.
1974: For the first time, the Society exceeded its 5 percent spending limit. Investment income, total income, and the operating surplus (deficit) are shown both with and without the 5 percent spending limit imposed. This presentation continues for the rest of the financial tables.
1975: After 1975, the data shown are compiled from audited financial statements (using accrual fund accounting) instead of from annual reports (using cash accounting) as had been done previously. (1979 and 1980 are exceptions; the audited financial statements were not available.)
1986: This "year" lasted only six months because the Society converted to a fiscal year ending June 30.
This table shows how the calculation was done to show what the value of the Society's endowment would be if it had held to a 5 percent spending limit. The table works as follows:
At the beginning of 1975, the market value of the Society's endowment stood at $10,455,000 (see upper left portion of table). The three-year-moving-average market value of the Society's endowment for 1974, 1973, and 1972 was $10,805,000. Using the spending rule of 5 percent, the Society would be allowed to spend $699,000 in 1975 (lower left part of table). Assuming that spending was spread out evenly over the course of the year, the equivalent of half of that amount, or $349,000, would appreciate during the year. Similarly, one-half of the $2,000 in capital gifts, $1,000, would earn a return over the course of the year. Summing the beginning-of-the-year market value, one-half of the funds spent, and one-half of the funds received results in a market value base of $10,805,000.
The market value base is used to calculate the amount of appreciation in the Society's investments during the year. Using a composite average return of 31.6 percent (calculated from average returns published by Cambridge Associates), the market value after appreciation but before spending and gifts received is estimated as $14,214,000. The Society's assumed 5 percent level of spending is then subtracted and actual gifts received are added, yielding an estimate of the year-end market value of the Society's endowment of $13,565,000 for 1975 if spending had been limited to 5 percent. The same sequence of calculations is then repeated through 1993.
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
The suggestions contained in this report are proposed as a statement of policy in determining future library acquisitions.
Two factors have particularly influenced decision in this matter (1) the strength of collections at present in the library, and (2) the proximity of two large libraries (Columbia University Library and The New York Public Library) in this area.
Before considering the collections in The New-York Historical Society Library, however, it seems proper here to mention two aspects of general acquisition policy. It has been the practice in instances of purchases of material for $100.00 or more, to await action by the Library Committee and the Board, or in cases where immediate action was necessary, to refer decision to the President of the Society. It is suggested that this practice be continued. When gifts of library material are offered it is suggested that such material be accepted with the understanding that if it does not complement already existing collections this material can be offered for exchange or otherwise used to benefit the library. Thus, the thoughtfulness of donors may be rewarded by the knowledge that the gifts which they have presented have been, in one way or other, of benefit to the library.
Limitations concerning primary material in the following report are not designed to eliminate the acquisitions of material principally concerning New Yorkers or of distinct New York interest.
In the report which follows, the expression "Primary material" shall be construed to mean diaries, journals, and letters in manuscript form, official documents and "rare books."
The following material briefly described constitutes the major collections in the library.
This collection includes thousands of books and pamphlets concerning slavery and reconstruction. Among the pamphlets are sermons, tracts, etc., in defense of, or against slavery. The collection is used regularly and will be used even more, it is safe to say, in view of the great interest in the background of the Civil War.
Some idea of the strength of this collection may be ascertained from the following statistics, relating to the number of titles listed under Slavery in the three major research libraries in the area:
New York Public Library 5,000
Columbia University Library 3,000
The New-York Historical Society Library 9,135
The bulk of our California Gold Rush material was originally collected as a result of the interest of a former librarian who migrated to California during the Gold Rush days. The collection consists of newspapers, pamphlets, early guides to California, etc.
Our material relating to the Southwest exploration period is a collection essentially of historical society reprints, general histories, etc. Its value to the researcher consists in the general material which would supplement more detailed studies.
This collection was donated to the Society in the nineteenth century by the historian J. Buckingham Smith. The material relates primarily to early Florida but there is also material dealing with Central America and Spanish rule in the area. A large part of this collection—consisting of manuscript maps and printed items pertaining directly to Florida—was microfilmed some years ago for the University of Florida. We no longer add to this collection since other libraries pursue the subject more extensively.
It is suggested that no further additions of primary or secondary material be made to this collection.
This is a good collection of the accounts and record of prisoners captured by American Indians. The collection, instituted in 1809, has been added to as opportunity presents. (It may be of interest to note that the largest collection of this material is owned privately by the Deering family of Saco, Maine. This collection consists of some 750 copies, which include various editions of the same titles.) The Newberry Library in Chicago has some 650 titles, the largest of the collections in any library open to the public. Many of these are also various editions of the same titles. The New York Public Library and the American Antiquarian Society Library have large collections. Our library has some 150 copies which also include various editions of the same titles.
It is suggested that we continue to add primary material to this collection but that no secondary material be added.
Our collection of 18th century newspapers is the fourth largest in the country. We collect U.S. newspapers through 1820, with particular emphasis on the Eastern Seaboard. We attempt to obtain procurable New York State newspapers in the nineteenth century, especially for the first twenty-five or forty years of a particular community when such material, generally scarce, is of greater historical value. In this connection, it is worth noting that except for sporadic collecting by the New York State Library there appears to be little planned collecting, by institutions, of New York State newspapers of the nineteenth century.
Outside of New York State our collecting is chiefly confined to early newspapers, as noted above. Where exceptions exist the material has generally come by gift. We have however been successful in exchanging out-of-state later nineteenth century newspapers for New York State newspapers of a similar period.
The newspaper collection is used constantly and is, in every sense, an active collection. The emphasis placed on the newspaper as a source of social history accounts, undoubtedly, for the steady use of our holdings.
It is suggested that the present practice of adding to our collection of 18th century newspapers and for the first twenty-five years or so of a particular community in New York State be continued.
Our collection of local histories is comprehensive. This is especially true for the New York State and Eastern Seaboard area. These histories, especially those written during the nineteenth century, are invaluable for biographical, political and geographical data. Local histories of middlewestern, far western states, etc., are confined chiefly to county histories and are used as general reference material.
Our circus material—posters, pamphlets, route books, biographies, memoirs, etc.—is unusually comprehensive. Much of the material relating to the circus in America has come by gift (e.g., the Leonidas Westervelt Collection) and the rest has been purchased over the years.
It is suggested that this Collection be added to as opportunity presents.
The Naval History Society gave its library to our Society and, in addition, also donated funds for the purchase of more material (Naval History Fund). The Naval History Society Collection, accompanied by catalog, covers the United States Naval History from the Revolution through World War I. It includes biographies of naval leaders, accounts of naval campaigns, histories of naval vessels, etc. We continue to purchase, through the funds provided, naval histories prior to World War I, but we have not attempted to collect naval historical and campaign material relating to World Wars I and II, except for some official government publications in the field of naval historical and campaign material. This material is used by researchers in our library and the collection is an active one. It is suggested that the Library should actively collect primary material in U.S. Naval History through the Spanish-American War. This terminal date seems practical because of the large Lathrop C. Harper Collection of Spanish-American War material. It is suggested that for the period after 1898 the Society should accept primary material offered as gifts and should continue to purchase primary material related to New York City and State. It is further suggested that the purchase of secondary material should be limited to outstanding histories on the basis of reviews in selective historical journals.
As in the case of our naval history collection we received the libraries of two organizations interested in military history. The libraries of The Seventh Regiment— New York National Guard and The Military Order of the Loyal Legion of the United States were given to us. Funds were not provided, however, by either of these organizations for the purchase of further material and we add to our collection of military history from regular special funds. Spanish-American War material was donated five years ago by Mrs. Lathrop C. Harper, together with funds, later added, for purchase in this field.
Our collection of military history contains army lists, orderly books, muster rolls, adjutant generals' reports, related journals and periodicals. Our area of collecting in military history extends from the Colonial period through the Spanish-American War, and to a certain degree, through World War I; with emphasis only on official campaign documents for World War II. We are unusually strong in the Colonial Wars, Revolutionary War, War of 1812, Civil War, and Spanish-American War material. Our Mexican War material is less strong than that of other wars but it is, nonetheless, an adequate collection. This collection of printed pamphlets and books is supplemented by broadsides and posters in the Map and Print Room and by material in the Manuscript Collection.
The collection of military manuals which we have consists of field exercise instructions, cavalry tactics, etc., and while it extends through the Civil War we make special efforts to obtain Revolutionary War and War of 1812 data.
It is suggested that the Library pursue an acquisition policy similar to that suggested in connection with the naval history collection, i.e., for the period after 1898 the Society should accept primary material offered as gifts and should continue to purchase primary material related to New York City and State. It is further suggested that the purchase of secondary material should be limited to outstanding military histories on the basis of reviews in selective historical journals.
In view of the strong collection of Civil War material we have, it seems advisable here to discuss this material in more detail. The range in this area is very much wider than that of other wars. We have over 11,000 titles, and these titles touch on every aspect of the Civil War, i.e. economic, political, social, industrial, etc. The Civil War collections include regimental histories (not only of New York but of other states), official records, memoirs, prison life accounts, reminiscences, rosters, histories of battles and campaigns, etc. The size and scope of this collection apparently are due to systematic collecting in the past by our Trustee, Daniel Parish, Jr., and others. In so far as the other two major libraries in the city are concerned (Columbia University Library and The New York Public Library) the New-York Historical Society Library has the largest collection of Civil War material [As of February 7, 1958: 4,000 titles at Columbia; 8,120 at New York Public Library].
There are differences, however, in the three collections (Columbia, N-YHS, NYPL). Columbia has a good collection of standard secondary material and some primary material, but in effect, it is a college and university 'working' library. (As evidence of this Columbia graduate students come to our library and to the NYPL to pursue some intensive research.) It is the least comprehensive and helpful from a research point of view, of the three collections.
The NYPL, however, has an outstanding Civil War collection. Among the material are regimental histories which comprise all possible histories of Northern and Southern regiments (although Southern regimental histories in any case are less common than for those of the Northern states). In fact, so comprehensive is this collection of regimental histories that the present Chief of the American History Division stated recently that it is difficult to acquire any more regimental histories because the collection is so complete.
On the other hand, The N-YHS Library has a larger collection—in comparison with the NYPL—of memoirs, reminiscences and recollections of the war, as seen by various participants. It is safe to say that the two libraries (N-YHS and NYPL) are about equal in the number of accounts of prison life, both North and South. They are not necessarily equal in the sense that we duplicate one another since we have material they do not have, and vice versa. The New York Public Library is stronger in economic histories of the Civil War, which include accounts of financial developments, currency fluctuations and the like. At the same time, the NYPL's diplomatic records of the war—i.e., relation with foreign countries and vice versa—is more complete than ours. It is also stronger in Confederate imprints.
It might be advisable to concentrate on New York material (which we do not overlook in any event) and also to attempt to collect primary material outside of the areas in which the NYPL is strongest (political, economic, and diplomatic aspects of the war).
In any case, the collections in the NYHS and the NYPL do not constitute complete duplication in Civil War material. It is currently the policy at the New York Public Library to purchase almost all Civil War material now published. In one area, for example, the purchase of regimental histories relating to regiments outside of New York State we might, in view of the NYPL collection, consider discontinuing such purchases.
Our collection of sheet music is based, essentially, on the illustrations which appear on the covers of early sheet music. In most cases the illustrations portray scenes no longer existing, and, in other instances, provide the only illustrations available of buildings or streets or views of a city. The emphasis in this collection is on New York City and State material. We also have a collection of Civil War sheet music, for example, which is valuable in view of the great interest in this period. Mrs. Landauer purchases sheet music for her collection which frequently eliminates the necessity for using regular library funds.
Our collection of songsters is an old one which was begun in the late nineteenth century and is added to from time to time. The emphasis is basically on New York City and State material.
It is suggested, in view of the holdings of the NYPL in which there is a comprehensive collection of American sheet music and songsters, that no further additions be made to this collection.
Our hotel material was donated to us. In the case of contemporary hotel material, the collection consists of indexed clippings, photographs and press releases (which are given to us) and the collection at present is kept up to date by the voluntary efforts of the widow of the donor. The emphasis here is on New York City hotels but, since many of the New York hotels are parts of nation-wide chains, the collection in some instances covers hotels outside of New York.
The earlier hotel material consists largely of engravings, photographs, etc., of early hotels in New York City and in some of the major Eastern Seaboard cities. Requests for reproductions of this material come to us by mail and telephone and it has useful reference value. In general, it is correct to state that we add very little by purchase since the collection attracts material from interested donors. [As of this writing our material is in use in connection with a forthcoming history of the Hotel Association of New York City.]
The nucleus of our menu collection is the Arnold Shircliffe menu collection of 10,000 items, which was donated to us by Mr. Shircliffe's son. There are some 18th century menus, but the bulk of the collection consists of 19th and early 20th (to approximately 1940) menus. These items are from restaurants all over the United States.
Supplementing the collection above are menus received by gift, or those which come to us from the public relations departments of contemporary restaurants. It is seldom that we add material, through purchase, to this collection. We receive almost all menus as gifts.
There is always an interest in menus either from the point of view of social history or for commercial purposes on the part of magazines and other restaurants. This collection is used regularly.
It is suggested that no further additions, except as relating to New York State, be made to this collection.
Our collection of biographies is unusually good in the field of American history. In general, these are biographies of national figures: political, military, etc. We have also acquired biographies of persons prominent in New York City and New York State who may not, necessarily, have achieved national prominence.
This is a working reference collection which supplements our other material.
This collection consists of general histories of the Spanish exploration period. We do not add to it with any regularity since there are strong collections in the city. It is suggested that no further material be added to this collection.
This collection consists of an unusual group of American travel accounts with emphasis on early American travels. Included in these printed books are descriptions of localities and events which are invaluable records of history as it happened. Only relatively outstanding accounts of contemporary travels are purchased since this field is crowded with innumerable superficial or 'picture-book' volumes of little worth.
It is suggested that we continue to buy accounts of travel in America undertaken prior to 1850. For the period 1850 to 1900 it is suggested that secondary material be purchased only selectively on the basis of reviews in the outstanding historical journals.
Our collection of early trials—the majority prior to 1850—is unusually strong. These reports of trials range from crudely printed pamphlets and leaflets to more detailed legal accounts. The emphasis, however, is on the social aspect of American history, rather than on the legal history of the period before 1850. These trials were often not reported in the press of the time because of the absence of newspapers in the vicinity of the trials.
The collection, which is well known, has been in the library and added to when possible, for many years. Additions to it are fairly uncommon, however, since this material is rare and does not often appear for sale.
It is suggested that we do not purchase accounts of trials after 1850.
This collection represents American drama up to 1860, with emphasis on late 18th and early 19th century drama. We do not purchase late 19th or 20th century drama, a field adequately covered by the larger university libraries. (As a supplement to this collection we have some special material relating to artists such as Jenny Lind and the concert singer Emma Thursby.)
Supplementing the collection further are a number of standard reference works relating to the theatre of the 18th and 19th centuries.
It is suggested that only material of special interest relating to New York and New York State be added for the period up to, and including, 1900.
This is a strong collection, well publicized, whose beginnings can be traced to gifts received from donors during the 19th century.
[Frequent letters from faculty members in colleges, both within and outside of New York, demonstrate the value of these volumes. In this connection a fairly recent bibliography of early American fiction by Lyle Wright (American Fiction: A Contribution toward a Bibliography, 1744—1850. San Marino: 1948) lists many of our titles. It should be noted that only in rare instances is this collection added to by purchase beyond the 1850 date. Exceptions occur only in the case of works by minor New York City or New York State authors whose works would probably not be collected by the average public or university library.]
It is suggested that only American fiction, poetry and belles-lettres of especial New York City and New York State interest be acquired through 1900.
The library has a large collection of collective and family genealogies. There is strong emphasis on New York City and State families. Genealogies of southern and western families are no longer collected, except in so far as they bear directly on families prominent in the eastern seaboard states during the 18th century. Many of these genealogies have come to us as gifts and the practice is still fairly common. They are frequently of value to the biographer and historian as well as the genealogist.
It is suggested that except for New York City and State families, no genealogies be added to this collection. This suggestion is offered in view of the statement of the Chief of the American History division of The New York Public Library who advises that it is now the policy of that library to acquire a copy of every printed genealogy relating to families in the United States. At the same time The New York Public Library pursues a policy of selective purchase of British (including Canadian) genealogies. Added to the above is the existence of The New York Genealogical and Biographical Society Library in the city.
Under this category may be classed early United States histories and reference books relating to art and architecture (for museum research). Much of this material, over the years, has been donated. We have endeavored to purchase only such books and pamphlets as complement areas in which we have strong collections. Certain basic reference books are properly classed in this category (directories, lists, etc.). Under this category also may be classed such printed material relating to 18th and early 19th centuries as religious history; medical histories including such items as accounts of epidemics in early New York City and State; histories of early business and industrial firms; political histories, and some economic histories of the 18th and 19th centuries.
It is suggested that only material which has a specific reference tool value to the Library and/or to the Museum be purchased for the period after 1850.
This collection includes a complete list of Directories (including business Directories) and Guides. In addition, there are indexes to vital records, wills, newspaper records, etc., as well as early reports of New York City religious, benevolent, charitable, social, fraternal, patriotic, etc., organizations. The collection comprises partial files of early city departmental reports (health, fire, education, police, etc.) together with printed records of the Minutes of the Common Council, Proceedings of the Board of Aldermen, etc. Added to the maps and atlases in the Map and Print Room the collection of New York City material, through the 19th century, is most comprehensive.
It is suggested that this material be added to whenever possible.
Sets of official documents of colonial and state legislative journals, laws and executive documents, regional, county, city and town guides and directories and various institutional publications (large colleges and universities, local historical societies, etc.) comprise a cross-section of our New York State records. It is suggested that this material be added to whenever possible.
The map and print collections may be divided into eight general categories.
A. BROADSIDES
We have an unusually strong collection of broadsides through 1865. These items rarely come to the Library through donation and, as a result, must be acquired when possible through purchase. The broadsides we have, or buy supplement material in the field of printed books, e.g., War material, 18th century New York City proclamations, announcements, etc.
It is suggested that purchases in this area be determined on the basis of die field in which the broadsides belong. These fields might be determined according to the suggestions already listed in the foregoing paragraph.
B. POLITICAL CARICATURES AND POSTERS TO 1900-1910
This is a large and useful collection of material relating to political campaigns, both of New York and the nation, through 1910. The posters relate to such varied fields as the circus in America, outstanding events in the history of New York and items relating to the Spanish-American War. Unlike the broadside collection we frequently receive gifts of material in this area.
It is suggested that we add to this collection as opportunity presents.
C. STEAMBOAT COLLECTION
This collection consists of nine albums of photographs (the George Murdock Collection) of steamboats which traveled the Hudson River and Long Island Sound in the 19th century. Supplementing this collection are illustrations—in one form or other—of famous steamboats of the 19th century.
D. MAPS AND ATLASES
This is a collection—strongest in 18th and early 19th century material—of maps of New York and the Eastern Seaboard. Included also are early railroad maps, atlases of the Civil War period, street maps of New York City, etc.
E. SILHOUETTES
This is a general collection of silhouettes from the Colonial period through 1844. Strongest in New York City material, and for the years 1790-1844, the collection also includes the work of silhouettists outside of New York.
It is suggested that no purchase of material later than 1844 be added to this collection.
E DAGUERREOTYPES
Primarily this collection is for the years 1850-1860 and the emphasis is on New Yorkers.
It is suggested, except for daguerreotypes of New Yorkers, that the terminal date for purchase of this material should be 1860.
G. ENGRAVED PORTRAITS, PHOTOGRAPHS AND LITHOGRAPHS
Our large collection of engraved portraits, photographs and lithographs consists of illustrations of prominent Americans with emphasis on the period up to 1920.
H. VIEWS OF AMERICAN CITIES— 18TH-19TH CENTURY
As the classification indicates, this collection consists of illustrations of American cities as they appeared in those centuries and the emphasis is usually on early views of American cities. Our New York City collection is exceptionally strong. In this connection the following comments and statistics relating to the holdings of four institutions in the city, including ours, may be of interest.
Early Views of New York City
New York Public Library: 500. It should be noted that the New York Public Library is not pursuing an active policy of acquiring New York City Views.
Columbia University Library: The holdings of this library are not
significant in number or quantity.
The New York Historical Society Library: 660. This figure includes material in the Museum Collection.
Museum of The City of New York—J.C. Davies and Arnold Collections: There are no figures available from this institution but the two collections cited are important sources for early views of New
York and other American cities.
The statistics relating to Early American cities, outside of New York City, to 1850 are as follows:
The New York Public Library: 560
Columbia University Library: The holdings are not outstanding in this area.
The New-York Historical Society Library: 741 (This figure includes material in the Museum Collection)
The Landauer Collection consists primarily of thousands of 19th century business cards, professional advertisements, catalogues, souvenirs used by 19th century business firms, etc. This material, because of its pictorial nature, is especially in demand by commercial photographers, magazine editors and the like.
Included in this collection are the early and later 19th century bookplates collected by Mrs. Landauer, which are supplemented, in turn, by two collections of bookplates of the late 19th and early 20th century donated to the Library.
[Mrs. Landauer adds to this collection from her own funds.]
The Manuscript Collection is one of the oldest in the Library. In 1813, only nine years after the Society was founded, fifty-one manuscripts were listed in the Society's Catalogue of its library. The collection now consists of over 300,000 single manuscripts and hundreds of bound volumes. Among these are papers of the Colonial and Revolutionary War periods, account books, diaries, journals, etc., of New York and early New Yorkers. The Manuscript Collection is particularly cohesive and is enriched, almost equally, by gift and purchase.
It is suggested that only material be purchased which has special relevance to material already in the collection.
As of March 1958 we received a total of 398 periodicals. Of these, 222 were paid subscriptions and 289 were received “by exchange.” This is explained by the fact that some of these “exchanges” are to individuals or to institutions in which we desiere to have our Quarterly represented.
Of the 398 different periodicals which were received, some arrive annually, some quarterly, etc.
| Presidents | |
| Egbert Benson, LL.D. | 1805-1815 |
| Gouverneur Morris | 1816 |
| DeWitt Clinton, LL.D. | 1817-1819 |
| David Hosack, M.D., LL.D. | 1820-1827 |
| James Kent, LL.D. | 1828-1831 |
| Morgan Lewis | 1832-1835 |
| Peter Gerard Stuyvesant | 1836-1839 |
| Peter Augustus Jay, LL.D. | 1840-1842 |
| Albert Gallatin, LL.D.' | 1843-1849 |
| Luther Bradish, LL.D. | 1850-1863 |
| Frederic De Peyster, LL.D. | 1864-1866 |
| Hamilton Fish, LL.D. | 1867-1869 |
| Thomas DeWitt, D.D. | 1869-1871 |
| Augustus Schell | 1872 |
| Frederic De Peyster, LL.D. | 1873-1882 |
| Augustus Schell | 1883-1884 |
| Benjamin Hazard Field | 1885-1886 |
| John Alsop King | 1887-1900 |
| Eugene Augustus HoflFman, D.D., LL.D. | 1901-1902 |
| Samuel Verplanck Hoffman | 1903-1912 |
| John Abeel Weekes | 1913-1939 |
| George A. Zabriskie, LL.D. | 1939-1947 |
| Fenwick Beekman, M.D. | 1947-1956 |
| Leroy E. Kimball, LL.D. | 1956-1962 |
| Irving S. Olds | 1962-1963 |
| Frederick B. Adams Jr. | 1963-1970 |
| Robert G. Goelet | 1970-1987 |
| Albert L. Key | 1987-1989 |
| Norman Pearlstine | 1989-1993 |
| Herbert S. Winokur Jr. | |
| and Wilbur L. Ross Jr. | 1993-1994 |
| Miner H. Warner | 1994- |
| Librarians | |
| John Forbes | 1805-1809 |
| John Pintard, LL.D. | 1810-1811 |
| John W. Francis, M.D. | 1812-1818 |
| Frederick C. Schaeffer, D.D. | 1819-1820 |
| Henry M. Francis, M.D. | 1821 |
| Matthew C. Patterson | 1822 |
| Henry W. Ducachet, M.D. | 1823 |
| Robert Greenhow, M.D. | 1824-1826 |
| Richard Ray | 1827 |
| James A. Hillhouse | 1828 |
| John Delafield Jr. | 1828-1830 |
| Samuel Ward III | 1831-1835 |
| Joseph Blunt | 1836-1839 |
| George W. Folsom | 1840-1841 |
| George Gibbs | 1842-1847 |
| Jacob B. Moore | 1848 |
| George H. Moore | 1849-1876 |
| John Austin Stevens | 1876-1878 |
| Jacob B. Moore | 1879-1887 |
| Charles Isham | 1888-1892 |
| William Kelby | 1893-1898 |
| Robert H. Kelby | 1898-1921 |
| Alexander J. Wall | 1921-1937 |
| Directors | |
| Alexander J. Wall | 1937-1944 |
| R.W.G. Vail, LittD., L.H.D. | 1944-1960 |
| James J. Heslin | 1960-1982 |
| James B. Bell | 1982-1988 |
| Barbara Knowles Debs | 1988-1992 |
| Betsy Gotbaum | 1993- |