The Setting
- Chris Smith was appointed five months ago as the assistant superintendent for instruction in the Peaceful Glen Central School District, a rural district located in our state. Chris is well respected by colleagues, teachers, students, and parents.
- For three years immediately preceding his appointment, Chris was the principal of the Peaceful Glen High School (PGHS). Prior to that, he was a teacher in that high school.
- Ellen Green, a teacher in the PGHS, has been the president of the Peaceful Glen Teachers’ Union for the past seven years.
- Throughout his tenure in the district, Chris has had a positive professional relationship with Ellen. In addition to working with her on several curriculum projects over the years, Chris was a member of the executive committee of the teachers’ union for the three years immediately preceding his appointment as principal.
- Chris has also had a positive personal relationship with Ellen and her husband, Tony. The two families live near each other in the same neighborhood. Chris and his wife often attend social events with Ellen and Tony. The children in the two families are good friends and are frequently at each others’ homes.
- The contract between the district and the teachers’ union expired 18 months ago and negotiations have been at a standstill for the past eight months. That the district and the union are “miles apart” on several matters is common knowledge. The rapport between the district and the union has mostly been professional and cordial. However, there are increasing sentiments among faculty and within some segments of the school community that teacher morale is rapidly waning and is beginning to affect the quality of instruction.
- The school day begins at 7:00 am for all support staff in the PGHS and at 7:30 am for all instructional staff; students arrive at 7:45 am.
- As Chris drives to the PGHS one morning at 7:15 am for a scheduled meeting with the new principal who began her duties last month, he notices the parking lot is unusually full of vehicles, including two from local television stations.
- As he searches for a place to park, Chris sees a large number of people in front of the building. While most are teachers in the PGHS, Chris recognizes many from other buildings in the school district. Chris also notices that the four daytime custodians are standing on the lawn adjacent to the sidewalk.
- The teachers are standing in a large group across the sidewalk in front of the main entrance doors to the building; several are carrying signs.
Today's Events
As Chris walks toward the entrance, he sees Ellen, two television reporters, and two camera operators walking toward him. Ellen approaches and, speaking into a megaphone, greets him by loudly stating rather than asking, “You aren’t going to cross through our line are you, Chris.”
Directions
Review the six 2008 Interstate School Leaders Licensure Consortium (ISLLC) standards and their respective functions. These were provided with the materials for this course; they are also available as a free PDF document from the following web address: http://www.ccsso.org/publications/index.cfm. Then, as a team, prepare to present and explain verbally and in writing (outline form on chart paper) to the class your responses to items A – D below:
- Based on the information provided above under the headings “The setting” and “Today’s events,” identify and come to consensus as a team on the leadership and/or the management issue(s) facing Chris. Provide your team’s rationale for your choice(s). You may wish to review the format used in the sections “Addressing the Critical Issues” following many of the scenarios in our course text (Green, 2009), such as those on pages 88 – 90, 121 – 123, and 154 – 156.
- Identify and come to consensus as a team which ISLLC standard(s) and which of its (their) functions your team believes should provide the overarching structure for how Chris should address the issue you have identified. Provide your team’s rationale for your choices.
- Based on your conclusions for items A and B above, identify and come to consensus as a team what in priority order your team believes Chris should do to successfully address your stated issue(s).
- Identify and come to consensus as a team on the consequences that may occur as a result of Chris doing what you identified in item C above.
- The time allotted for completing this activity is two hours.