Skip to content Skip to navigation

Connexions

You are here: Home » Content » How to obtain funding

Navigation

Recently Viewed

This feature requires Javascript to be enabled.
 

How to obtain funding

Module by: Rice ADVANCE. E-mail the author

Summary: Panel discussion presented by Rob Rafael at the 2011 NSF ADVANCE Workshop: Negotiating the Ideal Faculty Position, A Workshop for Underrepresented PhDs and Postdocs in Science, Engineering and Psychology September 18-20, 2010

Funding Is Critical

  • Must be prepared to work hard to garner funding
  • Need more than a great idea, though that is a crucial element
  • Need to understand the logistics and the process
  • Need to submit more than one grant, so need multiple ideas
  • Be creative
  • Read deeply and broadly
  • Talk to lots of people about research
  • Think about doing more than one project
    • When one is difficult, the other may succeed
    • Increases funding opportunities
    • Promotes synergy in thinking
    • Enhances visibility
  • What are the sources available to you?
    • Federal (NSF, NIH, DARPA, DOE, NIST, ONR, among many others)
    • State
    • Private foundations / not-for-profit organizations
    • Industry
  • Use the web to retrieve information for each source
    • Some more detailed, others more obscure

Find Out About Resources

  • Talk to your advisor, faculty in your department about resources in your area of research and in your institution
  • Use the internet
    • Search for information on organization, what it supports to determine whether to target for funding
    • Search for deadline dates and invitations to apply in a given area
    • Search services such as IRIS http://iris.library.uiuc.edu/~iris/alert/
  • Government agencies have detailed pages
    • Easy to get lost
    • Ask for help
  • GrantsNet (http://www.grantsnet.org) from AAAS has good links
  • Grant Writing (many now available)
    • Proposal Writer’s Guide (Thackery)
    • Research Proposals: A Guide to Success (Ogden and Goldberg)

Get To Know Funders

  • How are proposals reviewed?
  • What is the timing?
  • What do they support?
    • How can you target your research appropriately?
  • Is there someone you know associated with the funding agency?
    • Talk to them!
    • Go to DC and talk to them!

Reasons to Talk to Program Folks

  • If you have great, but risky ideas, talk with the program officer to see how best to present them
  • Ask what a reasonable budget range would be
  • Ask about the role of collaborators in your area of research

How to Approach an Agency

  • Options for contact
    • Go in person or make a phone call
    • Find an agency person at a national meeting (they often attend to get to know their grantees)
  • Be prepared and take as little of their time as possible while getting your message across
  • Introduce yourself as a new independent researcher with some general information about yourself
  • Have a specific question (or two) and ask if they have any specific advice

Understand the Submission Process

Find the resources from your institution that support grant submission

  • Federal agencies may differ from foundations
  • Get to know what they can do to help you identify the appropriate agency
  • Get to know what they can do to help you with the process
  • Understand the timeline and plan accordingly

Get Organized

  • Find and read resources that help with grant preparation
  • Ask senior colleagues if they will read your proposal and provide feedback
  • Ask successful colleagues if you can read their grant
  • Try to get onto a review panel (it will change your views!!!)
  • Think deeply about your project — be innovative and creative in tackling a significant problem
  • Identify the potential sources
    • Find the due dates (both agency and internal!)
    • Determine which applications to pursue
    • Develop your timeline for thinking, writing, rewriting, writing/rewriting, writing/rewriting, etc., final proofreading (critical!) — find out about institutional deadlines you must meet!!
  • Be sure that you get feedback from colleagues before submission
    • Include plenty of time for this step in your timeline
    • Provides key perspective/input

Proposal Elements

Budget — know deadlines in your institution! Get help, if needed!

  • Carefully crafted to align with anticipated funding from target
  • Must be approved by department, dean, institution
  • Can sometimes be sent through institutional process before the full grant
  • Get feedback from experienced grant writers!

Budget Elements

  • Salaries (PI, students, technical help) + Fringe benefits
  • Equipment
  • Supplies
  • Travel
  • Other (e.g., publication expenses)
  • Subcontracts
  • Indirect costs – F&A costs (facilities and administration, negotiated by institution)
  • Fringe benefits and F &A costs set by institution

Proposal Elements

  • Research plan (usually in a specified order) — other items may be requested
    • Hypotheses/specific goals
    • Significance
    • Background
    • Prior results of relevance/preliminary data
    • Include collaborators if you need their expertise
    • Experimental plan
    • Timeline
  • No types, clear headers, some white space, use figures/tables
  • Clear flow from hypotheses to experiments to concluding section
  • Follow agency format precisely
  • Include, where permissible, preliminary data/figures

Other Documents

  • Different agencies require different types of documentation
  • Read instructions very, very carefully and produce proposal accordingly
    • How to organize proposal
    • How to submit
    • What is allowed, not allowed
    • Criteria for review

Reviewer Issues

  • Don’t assume reviewer will be an expert in your specific area
    • Give appropriate background, with proper referencing for the experts
    • Create a cohesive, interesting “story”
  • If you are responding to a review (e.g., NIH, NSF and others allow resubmission), formulate your response in affirming and polite tones, even if the reviewer was wrong

Research Plan

  • Carefully present the importance of what you propose
  • Leave no question that you can accomplish what you propose
    • Be sure to indicate alternate routes in case what you propose does not work
  • Be very thorough in your citations (someone in the area will review it!)

Proposal Elements

  • “Broader impacts”
    • NSF specifically requires that a proposal include activities that address the engagement of society with science
    • Proposed activities vary widely
    • Discuss with your institution what others have done that has been successful
  • Other agencies are beginning to request information on activities beyond the research plan (e.g., NIH and postdoctoral training)

How Much Is Too Much?

Think carefully about what you can reasonably do in the time frame of the grant

  • Don’t assume everything will work the first time (or even that it will work)
  • Don’t try to do more than you honestly feel is possible
  • Be aware that reviewers will probably know better about timing than you - get advice!

Good Advice*

  • Calm down
  • Understand the situation
  • Communicate clearly

“This set of advice is good to repeat to yourself at intervals, and it is sometimes hard to do any, much less all, of these!”
*From We Were Soldiers

What “Voice”?

  • Using first person can seem arrogant when read, but if you use it, be sure to use “we” unless you did all the work yourself
  • Write a few paragraphs in the first person and then read them; try them in a different voice and read them
  • Choose what fits you

Criteria for Review

  • Criteria vary with agency, so need to read instructions carefully
  • Examples of criteria (not exhaustive):
    • Intellectual merit / quality of proposed work
    • Innovation
    • Creativity of original concepts
    • Well-conceived and organized activities
    • Investigator qualifications
    • Institutional context/access to resources
    • Broader impacts
  • Criteria used can vary depending on the type of grant
    • Research
    • Training
    • Small business innovation (e.g., SBIR)
  • Always read the instructions, which almost always provide information on criteria for review

Collaborating

Assess how collaborative funding is viewed in your department and your institution

  • Can be viewed positively
  • Can be viewed negatively
  • But remember you must have independent funding as a junior investigator for the P & T process

Ways to Prepare

  • Find publications on grant writing
  • Ask to see successful proposal submitted by your colleagues
  • Find out if your institution offers any grant-writing or grant draft-feedback activities (e.g., a mock review panel for your proposal)

Foundations

  • Proposal processes are highly idiosyncratic, so you have to know the requirements - quite individual
  • Foundations
    • National examples – sometimes nominations are by institution
      • Packard, Searle, Keck, Pew
    • Often have local foundations that should be explored
    • Funding very economy-dependent

Corporations

  • Contracts negotiated through institutional research office
  • Elements often negotiated (institutions normally try to charge F & A costs at some level)
  • Terms and amounts vary significantly
  • Ask about industry support at your institution or institution-of-interest if this type of support is important in your area

When You Are Funded

  • Be aware that the funds go to the institution for your use
  • Be fiscally responsible and keep up with your funding (learn how to read the budget monthly)
  • Be sure your students and staff are aware of costs and exercise good judgment in ordering

Don’t Let Funding Consume You

  • Publish!!!
  • Collaborate when possible
    • Shared techniques/approaches/new ideas
  • Discuss your ideas
  • Read
  • Be brave
  • Be prepared to fail!
  • And then write the next grant…..

Enjoy The Process!

  • You can do the research that you love and choose the students and collaborators with whom you will work!
  • Be sure that you include relaxation in your planning and put thought into how to balance your work/life along the way! It can be great fun!

Content actions

Download module as:

PDF | EPUB (?)

What is an EPUB file?

EPUB is an electronic book format that can be read on a variety of mobile devices.

Downloading to a reading device

For detailed instructions on how to download this content's EPUB to your specific device, click the "(?)" link.

| More downloads ...

Add module to:

My Favorites (?)

'My Favorites' is a special kind of lens which you can use to bookmark modules and collections. 'My Favorites' can only be seen by you, and collections saved in 'My Favorites' can remember the last module you were on. You need an account to use 'My Favorites'.

| A lens I own (?)

Definition of a lens

Lenses

A lens is a custom view of the content in the repository. You can think of it as a fancy kind of list that will let you see content through the eyes of organizations and people you trust.

What is in a lens?

Lens makers point to materials (modules and collections), creating a guide that includes their own comments and descriptive tags about the content.

Who can create a lens?

Any individual member, a community, or a respected organization.

What are tags? tag icon

Tags are descriptors added by lens makers to help label content, attaching a vocabulary that is meaningful in the context of the lens.

| External bookmarks